| 09.02.2025 |  NAT | St Joseph's St Joseph's | 0 - 0 | Lincoln Red Imps FC Lincoln Red Imps FC | | |
| 24.10.2024 | NAT | Lincoln Red Imps FC Lincoln Red Imps FC | 0 - 0 | St Joseph's St Joseph's | | |
| 11.05.2024 | NAT | St Joseph's St Joseph's | 1 - 1 | Lincoln Red Imps FC Lincoln Red Imps FC | | |
| 22.12.2023 | NAT | Lincoln Red Imps FC Lincoln Red Imps FC | 1 - 2 | St Joseph's St Joseph's | | |
| 29.09.2023 | NAT | St Joseph's St Joseph's | 1 - 0 | Lincoln Red Imps FC Lincoln Red Imps FC | | |
| 15.04.2023 | NAT | St Joseph's St Joseph's | 0 - 3 | Lincoln Red Imps FC Lincoln Red Imps FC | | |
| 05.02.2023 | NAT | Lincoln Red Imps FC Lincoln Red Imps FC | 1 - 0 | St Joseph's St Joseph's | | |
| 09.10.2022 | NAT | St Joseph's St Joseph's | 2 - 2 | Lincoln Red Imps FC Lincoln Red Imps FC | | |
| 14.04.2022 | NAT | St Joseph's St Joseph's | 1 - 2 | Lincoln Red Imps FC Lincoln Red Imps FC | | |
| 13.02.2022 | NAT | Lincoln Red Imps FC Lincoln Red Imps FC | 3 - 2 | St Joseph's St Joseph's | | |
| 06.12.2021 | NAT | St Joseph's St Joseph's | 0 - 1 | Lincoln Red Imps FC Lincoln Red Imps FC | | |
| 14.05.2021 | NAT | St Joseph's St Joseph's | 2 - 2 | Lincoln Red Imps FC Lincoln Red Imps FC | | |
| 25.04.2021 | NAT | Lincoln Red Imps FC Lincoln Red Imps FC | 0 - 1 | St Joseph's St Joseph's | | |
| 05.03.2021 | NAT | Lincoln Red Imps FC Lincoln Red Imps FC | 4 - 2 | St Joseph's St Joseph's | | |
| 08.02.2020 | NAT | St Joseph's St Joseph's | 1 - 0 | Lincoln Red Imps FC Lincoln Red Imps FC | | |
| 14.12.2019 | NAT | St Joseph's St Joseph's | 2 - 1 | Lincoln Red Imps FC Lincoln Red Imps FC | | |
| 06.04.2019 | PRE | St Joseph's St Joseph's | 1 - 3 | Lincoln Red Imps FC Lincoln Red Imps FC | | |
| 04.01.2019 | PRE | Lincoln Red Imps FC Lincoln Red Imps FC | 1 - 3 | St Joseph's St Joseph's | | |
| 02.10.2018 | PRE | St Joseph's St Joseph's | 0 - 5 | Lincoln Red Imps FC Lincoln Red Imps FC | | |
| 03.06.2018 | PRE | Lincoln Red Imps FC Lincoln Red Imps FC | 0 - 3 | St Joseph's St Joseph's | | |
| 08.04.2018 | PRE | St Joseph's St Joseph's | 4 - 2 | Lincoln Red Imps FC Lincoln Red Imps FC | | |
| 30.11.2017 | PRE | Lincoln Red Imps FC Lincoln Red Imps FC | 2 - 0 | St Joseph's St Joseph's | | |
| 21.05.2017 | PRE | St Joseph's St Joseph's | 0 - 1 | Lincoln Red Imps FC Lincoln Red Imps FC | | |
| 28.02.2017 | PRE | Lincoln Red Imps FC Lincoln Red Imps FC | 2 - 2 | St Joseph's St Joseph's | | |
| 03.12.2016 | PRE | St Joseph's St Joseph's | 1 - 2 | Lincoln Red Imps FC Lincoln Red Imps FC | | |
| 17.04.2016 | PRE | St Joseph's St Joseph's | 0 - 3 | Lincoln Red Imps FC Lincoln Red Imps FC | | |
| 16.01.2016 | PRE | Lincoln Red Imps FC Lincoln Red Imps FC | 4 - 0 | St Joseph's St Joseph's | | |
| 08.11.2015 | PRE | St Joseph's St Joseph's | 0 - 2 | Lincoln Red Imps FC Lincoln Red Imps FC | | |
| 16.05.2015 | PRE | Lincoln Red Imps FC Lincoln Red Imps FC | 2 - 1 | St Joseph's St Joseph's | | |
| 21.02.2015 | PRE | St Joseph's St Joseph's | 2 - 4 | Lincoln Red Imps FC Lincoln Red Imps FC | | |
| 01.11.2014 | PRE | Lincoln Red Imps FC Lincoln Red Imps FC | 2 - 0 | St Joseph's St Joseph's | |
|